Universitas Dian Nuswantoro, through researchers Fatimah, Yun Arifatul; Govindan, Kannan; Sasongko, Nugroho Adi; and Hasibuan, Zainal A., conducted a study on critical success factors for sustainable resource management in the circular economy, with a focus on assessing the maturity level of urban mining. The activity addressed the increasing generation of electronic waste associated with population growth, urbanization, industrialization, and the consumption of modern products. It also responded to the lack of agreement among researchers and practitioners regarding how success in the e-waste circular economy should be measured.
The study identified critical success factors for the e-waste circular economy and developed urban mining maturity levels through Key Performance Indicators derived from the execution of those factors. Automatic Content Analysis was applied to extract keywords and interpret relationships among keywords from related articles on e-waste management. The resulting initial factors were further examined by subject experts through facet analysis to construct Key Performance Indicators aligned with the critical success factors. The maturity level was modeled by adding the scores of the Key Performance Indicators. Expert scores classified urban mining into initial, emerging, developing, established, and mature stages.
The study identified seven critical success factors and 34 Key Performance Indicators. Indonesia, India, and Japan were used as trial countries for the assessment. Indonesia and India were assessed at the emerging level, while Japan reached the established stage. The results provide guidance for choosing and prioritizing the Sustainable Development Goals. In particular, the study relates urban mining indicators to SDG 9, SDG 11, and SDG 12, among other Sustainable Development Goals. This activity therefore frames UDINUS research as contributing to evidence-based assessment of e-waste circular economy practices and sustainable urban resource management.