Skip to content
SDGs Center UDINUS

Evidence record · UDINUS · SDGs

A Comparative Analysis of Organic and Conventional Horticultural Farming in the Getasan District, Semarang, Indonesia

Rektorat UDINUS 2023 Published 2026-10-30

Evidence record · UDINUS · SDGs

Unit
Rektorat UDINUS
Period
2023
Goals
Record
9f6cd3d4-1a85-4189-90fd-afaa1dfdfc6f
Published
2026-10-30

Universitas Dian Nuswantoro (UDINUS), through researchers Asfawi, S., Utomo, D., and Isworo, S., conducted a comparative study of organic and conventional horticultural farming systems in Getasan District, Semarang. The activity examined organic horticulture as a farming technique that relies on natural materials in production and compared it with conventional horticulture, which still relies on chemicals in its production process. The study compared production costs, yields, income, profit, soil nutrient restoration costs, fertilizer costs, and labor costs.

The research used a cross-sectional descriptive-analytical design and survey methodologies. It was conducted from July to December 2019 using 314 respondents as research subjects. The sample comprised 90 organic horticulture farmers and 224 conventional horticulture farmers. The analysis considered the average total additional cost of restoring soil nutrients, fertilizer purchasing costs, average yields during each growing season, annual income from yields, average profit, total annual production costs, and labor costs.

The average total additional cost of restoring soil nutrients for organic horticulture was IDR 69,958.33 per 100 m2 per year, compared with IDR 79,550.00 for conventional farming, with a p-value of 0.032. Fertilizer costs were IDR 73,170.38 per 100 m2 per year for organic horticulture and IDR 90,575.78 for conventional horticulture, with a p-value below 0.001. The average yield of organic horticulture farms was somewhat higher during each growing season.

Annual income from yields was IDR 2,449,246.32 per 100 m2 for organic production and IDR 2,369,641.10 for conventional production, although the difference was not statistically significant. Average profit was IDR 1,549,303.42 for organic horticulture and IDR 1,450,109.82 for conventional horticulture, also without statistical significance. Total annual production costs were lower for organic horticulture, while labor-cost differences were not statistically significant. Based on the parameters analyzed, the study reported that organic horticulture was superior to conventional horticulture.

Reference https://www.scopus.com/pages/publications/85172373222?origin=resultslist